Place in center of a piece of plastic wrap and roll into a log. And does it top tried-and-true methods like pan-searing? In the same amount of time it takes to air fry one steak, you can cook four steaks in a large cast-iron skillet. Instead, pan-sear your steak in a cast-iron skillet or stainless steel skillet. A perfectly seared steak can seem like a daunting task. Don’t miss the Test Kitchen’s other secrets for air fryer success. Need a foolproof, basic recipe? Next, set your air fryer to 400 degrees and pre-heat it for 3 minutes on any setting. Taste of Home is America's #1 cooking magazine. Don’t miss the Test Kitchen’s other secrets for air fryer success. Here’s another big issue: The Power Air Fryer XL can fit only one steak in its basket. For this test, I used the Power Air Fryer XL. Regardless, this steak loses serious points in the flavor department for lacking a sear on the outside. RELATED: 35+ Healthy Recipes You Can Make in an Air Fryer. For individuals asking how long do you cook a steak in an air fryer… Let the air fryer preheat for about three minutes before moving on. Cooking Light is part of the Allrecipes Food Group. On the inside, it was surprisingly juicy and moist. I have nothing against the air fryer. Add the steak to the air fryer basket and cook it for about 7 to 9 minutes for a medium-rare steak or 10 to 14 minutes for medium, flipping the steak halfway through. Lightly coat steaks with olive oil. Makinze is the Associate Food Editor for Faux-frying is what most people are using their air fryers for, but don’t stop there. The tabletop convection ovens are amazing, circulating hot air around your food until it gets a crisp exterior—just like a fryer, but with a whole lot less oil. Despite my skepticism, there are a plethora of recipes for air fryer steak all over the internet. Steak prepared using an air fryer are delicious and above all healthier than that cooked using a deep fryer. You want to be sure it has reached the Test Kitchen-recommended temperature. Wondering how to take your steak from good to great? While you’re waiting, remove excess fat from the edges of your steak—it should pull off easily, but you can use a sharp knife. On top of that, one particular model—the Power Air Fryer XL—even has a specific setting for cooking steak. It's true! VERY IMPORTANT! After years of working in professional kitchens, Lindsay traded her knives in for the pen. Credit: Here’s the exact ingredient breakdown and method I followed: Step OneBring the steak to room temperature (this helps it cook more evenly). While she spends most of her time writing these days, she still exercises her culinary muscles on the regular, taking any opportunity to turn local, seasonal ingredients into beautiful meals for her family. This ingredient shopping module is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page. In our testing, we found that cook times vary dramatically between brands of air fryers. Getty Images / Kativ / Amazon. So, with that said, there are plenty of delicious things you can make with an air fryer, but steak is not one of them. This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. Combine steaks, soy sauce, olive oil, and seasoning in a large resealable bag. Dinner Tonight: Quick and Healthy Menus in 45 Minutes (or Less), 35+ Healthy Recipes You Can Make in an Air Fryer. Flavor: 5 out of 10. Let us know how it went in the comments below! Start by rubbing the steak all over with the olive oil. As a result, we have given wider than normal ranges on suggested cook times. Elizabeth Laseter, Credit: You can cook some surprising foods in these gadgets, including air fryer steak. Air fryer steak immediately raises a red flag. Note: The Power Air Fryer XL has a steak preset, but I just don’t recommend using it. In a small bowl, combine butter and herbs. Place the steak inside the air fryer basket, set the temperature to 400 degrees and the cook time for 7 minutes if you prefer medium-rare. We like to preheat the air fryer on the regular setting to 400° F. Let the air fryer preheat for about three minutes before moving on. Top steak with a slice of herb butter to serve. Offers may be subject to change without notice. On the bright side, seven minutes in the air fryer produced a flawless medium rare steak. Hands down, this was the saddest-looking steak I’ve ever cooked. Hear me out. (The same goes for bacon—you can read about that fiasco here.). Even the Test Kitchen is using air fryers! The best way to know when your steak is finished is to use a meat thermometer. It should take anywhere between 7 to 9 minutes for a medium-rare steak, and 10 to 14 minutes for a medium steak. Photo: Caitlin Bensel, Why You Should NEVER Cook Steak in Your Air Fryer. Place the steaks on top of the seasoning and now season the top of the steak in salt and pepper too. When the steak is finished cooking, let it rest for 10 minutes before slicing and serving. Place the steak in the air fryer basket with space between them. 4. Remove from the basket and let the steak rest, covered on a plate for five minutes. All Rights Reserved. © Copyright 2020 Meredith Corporation. Not all air fryers are created equal, so make sure to read the instruction manual for your particular model before cooking. It picked up ZERO sear in the air fryer, and it lacked the gorgeous, golden-brown crust you can get from a cast-iron skillet. Credit: We chose a thick cut ribeye here, but if you prefer a different cut of steak, you can still use the air fryer. Our 31-day calendar of meals and tips shows you how to cook more and love it with fun, family-friendly meals that come together quickly and deliciously. Serve it alongside some Air Fryer Potatoes! This content is imported from {embed-name}. To keep things nice and simple, I settled on a New York strip steak, which is lean, tender, and flavorful when cooked properly. I don’t know about you, but we’ve been swept up in the air fryer craze. What if we told you that your air fryer can take all of that stress away? It can make foods that are typically fried—like French fries, doughnuts, and chicken wings—a whole lot healthier by eliminating the need for excess oil. As for the herb butter? Twist ends together to keep tight and refrigerate until hardened, 20 minutes. This list will help you make it happen! 3. DO NOT PREHEAT THE AIR FRYER. Step TwoSeason the steak and rub it all over with olive oil.